Tuesday 28 April 2020

A Lifelong Lockdown


Photo by Brett Sayles from Pexels



It’s been 35 days since the lockdown began, and I think it’s fair to state that most of us feel as if we’re imprisoned in cages. That makes me wonder- isn’t this exactly how animals in captivity feel everyday? 

Well, their lives are just as bad as what we’re going through now - worse even. In fact, it is proven that being caged in zoos affects them psychologically. Numerous creatures in captivity, including bears, elephants, monkeys and several others, have developed a disease called zoochosis. Animals suffering from zoochosis are known to rock and sway, bite randomly and pace back and forth excessively. 

To prevent this, zoos often place animals in large enclosures so that they have space to roam around. However, these enclosures are never large enough. For example, a tiger usually needs 60 to 100 square kilometres, but a zoo enclosure can only provide about 22 square metres! Though zoos would like to keep this fact hidden, life in captivity is extremely traumatic for most animals. 

Zoos often defend themselves by claiming that by keeping these beasts, they are protecting them from endangerment. Well, if that’s truly their reason for capturing creatures, why not work towards safeguarding them in their own habitats instead? 

When animals are conserved in their own homes, there is a beneficial effect on the entire ecosystem surrounding them. A classic instance of this is when wolves were reintroduced into the Yellowstone National Park in the USA. Before the wolves were brought in, the numbers of deer had increased dramatically and they had destroyed most of the vegetation in the park by overgrazing. The wolves began to hunt these deer, forcing them to avoid certain parts of the park where they could be easily spotted. Hence, safe from overgrazing, the plants and trees in those parts of the park started to flourish. This led to birds and beavers moving in. The beavers built dams, which served as homes for several more species such as otters, ducks, fish, reptiles and amphibians. Eventually, this resulted in a change in the behaviour of the rivers! And that is why animals should be allowed to thrive in their own habitats.

Furthermore, there is substantial evidence of zoos mistreating animals, including a healthy giraffe being killed and fed to lions at Copenhagen Zoo in 2014 and elephants being beaten and chained at Mysore Zoo in the same year. Even without direct abuse, most animals in captivity die prematurely, because they are just not supposed to live in zoos. 

Several people argue that the existence of zoos is still acceptable as zoos educate their visitors about different species. However, there are a variety of studies that prove that these menageries exist only to make money, and not for any other noble purpose. For example, a survey conducted in four zoos in USA showed that 86% of visitors were only there for recreational, rather than educational, reasons. If you truly want to learn about different types of animals, you don’t have to visit a zoo for it. With today’s technology, you can learn so much by just sitting at home. 

Have you ever wondered what happens to the creatures that are no longer profitable to their zoos? Well, these “surplus” animals are usually just killed, and not in small numbers. In fact, the EAZA (European Association of Zoos and Aquaria) has estimated that its members cull between three and five thousand animals every year! Does your conscience really allow you to contribute to this murder just for entertainment?

Now that I’ve laid out the facts for you, it’s time for you to decide. Can you give up visiting these cruel establishments for the sake of thousands of animals around the globe? Or will you choose to encourage the torture and murder of living beings? The ball is in your court.

21 comments:

  1. Netra you have very nicely explained about the suffering of animals in zoos
    Unfortunately we humans are inhuman and this lockdown can be a lesson for us to change for the good

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you! I certainly hope it will be a lesson for us, and that we realize what it's like for animals locked up in zoos.

      Delete
  2. Very well explained and a different perspective about zoos. Yes definitely it is a lifelong lockdown for these animals and birds. Especially the birds of prey, for whom the sky is the limit. And large birds for whom the space is not enough to even exercise their wing muscles. In fact their wings are clipped. Yes it is absolutely inhumane.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks for reading and commenting! I'm glad you agree with me.

      Delete
  3. Very informative article - I particularly liked the title!

    ReplyDelete
  4. Excellent article Netra. Keep writing

    ReplyDelete
  5. Well said Netra. Now that we humans are being quarantined, the animals in the world must be the happiest. We can see scores of videos of them roaming freely in places inhabited by humans

    ReplyDelete
  6. Netra,it is a brilliant article.How true that the animals suffer and cannot even express.You have done a great help by bringing awareness.God bless you.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Hi Netra, to recognize the plight of animals in comparison with the present lockdown is laudable. We should do away with zoos. What about larger safaris? Is the life of animals better there? If so, only such safaris should exist. Right time for man to spare a thought for these hapless ones. Great work Netra. Keep writing. Rgds. Venkat.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks for your feedback. As most safaris let animals roam free, cases of animal trauma there are few. Safaris also allow you to see creatures in their own habitats, so I think they are definitely a better option than zoos.

      Delete
  8. It only takes a heart to understand tge plight of animals suffering to serve the human race. You got that sweet little girl and also the skill to write about them.. tonnes of love to you

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks for commenting Ambaree. Towards the end of our stay in Singapore, she refused to
      Visit the zoo and bird park saying that she regretted having contributed to them when she was younger

      Delete
  9. So nicely written Netru and I love your perspectives. I agree fully about your thoughts on zoos. I don't take the kids to such establishments anymore as they're not meant to be natural for the animals. Not going creates less demand to keep such places open.

    Education can be done in numerous ways by supporting wildlife conservation causes (either monetarily, pledging for their better treatment/banning poaching in game reserves on social media channels, pushing for better animal rights legislation) or simply having a plant-based diet. We can even learn about these creatures online with virtual tours nowadays.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks for reading and commenting! It's great to hear that you have stopped visiting zoos, as like you said, it reduces the demand to keep them open, and will eventually lead to less animals being captured and subjected to cruelty.

      Delete
  10. A very well written and thought provoking piece Netra, full of impactful arguments and facts. Keep it up!
    Shobana
    This health crisis as well as the lockdown will hopefully make us realise how important it is to let Nature be rather than exploiting it for our selfish needs.
    Shobana

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you for your feedback! It's very encouraging to see that so many people agree!

      Delete
  11. Very thought provoking netra.. I completely agree to your perspective. A close look at the animals at these establishments speaks volumes of the treatment they meet. They look lifeless!!

    ReplyDelete
  12. Your article is clear and sooo true!! Keep writing, you have a talent!!(btw Zarah here😁)

    ReplyDelete

Game, Set, Match: Saudi's Sportswashing Success

Image source The deserts of Saudi Arabia have come alive with sports. From its purchase of the Newcastle United football club, to the lau...